The current state of Paranormal site proposal could be confusing at first (what's on-topic or not). Given the fact that there are many downvotes, I think it's great to have a chat room where we can discuss what's relevant for the site and talk about any outstanding issues or questions in real-time. Where basically we should agree what would qualify to reside on the site.
This will allow us to improve on our quality and to talk about some questions in details, so we can introduce much better questions to achieve our goals for the Definition stage.
I hope that helps.