Should Chinese Medicine and usage of herbs for health purposes be on topic?

Proposal: Health

share
up vote 10 down vote accepted

Yes, in my opinion questions about everything that is meant to affect health should be on-topic.

As well as the questions about how the various things (like high heels etc.) affect health.

share
    
I infer that essential oils would also be on topic. – Kyle Hayes Mar 1 '15 at 1:46

If you say, be on topic, do you mean like whether people are allowed to ask that? Why shouldn't they be allowed to? I say of course they can. It's the task of the answerers to either prove their answer (let's say that some particular herb has an actual effect or not) with some studies or point out that it's just their opinion or experience (like maybe when acupuncture helped in one's case).

share

My personal opinion is that snake oil should be called out for what it is, so as a general rule no.

But on that note if there is something which can be objectively proven (yes I mean double blind trials with a control.) then I think it should be on topic.

share
3  
This stackexchange site would be a great opportunity to call out snake oil of what it is. A question "Will taking X affect ailment Y" with an answer "according to this double-blind study it won't affect it at all" would be a constructive asset to the site. For that reason questions about "alternative" medicine would be on-topic just for the answers which debunk them. Answers based on unproven and unscientific statements by charlatans will certainly be called out as such and downvoted. – Philipp Mar 24 '15 at 16:51
1  
intresting how I have recieved a crapton of downvotes on this one yet the only comment is a positive one :S – Damian Nikodem Mar 24 '15 at 23:38
3  
@DamianNikodem, I downvoted, and I also agree with Philipp's comment. I agree that snake oil should be called out in an answer, but that doesn't mean questions asking about such things should be off-topic, but rather the answers should try to get to the truth. – Kenshin Mar 25 '15 at 2:47
    
@Mew , Thankyou – Damian Nikodem Mar 25 '15 at 2:52

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .